Articles Comments

The Only Democracy? » On The Ground Reports » Guarnieri: “Israel’s ‘Street Apartheid'”

Guarnieri: “Israel’s ‘Street Apartheid'”

By Jesse Bacon

The excellent journalist Mya Guarnieri has a piece for Al Jazeera in which she focuses on the everyday inequality  of street conditions in East Jerusalem.

The difference can be as simple as a street light.

Al Jazeera found that stoplights that lead to Jewish settlements and neighborhoods stay green for an average of a minute and a half. In Palestinian areas, it’s 20 seconds. One light in predominantly Arab East Jerusalem is green for less than 10 seconds.”

In our road-driven culture, street lights are as good a symbol of any of mobility and restriction. What’s more they are an example of unseen authority, and seem to go off indiscriminately, a. But they do discriminate. Well done, Al Jazeera for picking up on that.

In Palestinian areas of Jerusalem. Roads are poorly maintained. They are narrow and bumpy, riddled with cracks and potholes. Street signs and sidewalks are almost non-existent.

Trash containers are usually communal and there are often too few to meet the needs of the neighborhood. Pedestrians, forced to walk on the shoulder of the road, wade through garbage.

Jewish neighborhoods and settlements, on the other hand, are neat and orderly. Sidewalks and traffic circles keep pedestrians safe; roads are well-marked, some with lit signs. Most buildings have a garbage bin and the streets are free of litter.

The part of the article about roads reminded me of stories old Hyde Parkers used to tell me of when the Chicago Machine used to refuse to pick up the garbage in their neighborhood (now famous as President Obama’s) as punishment for their supporting independent candidates. Thankfully, Chicago finally got a reformist mayor who ended that practice, though of course you still have class discrimination in neighborhoods in terms of their appearance. And at least many Chicagoans are citizens. Jerusalemite Palestinians are only “Residents,” which the article explains they have to be particularly vigilant about paying taxes for a government that discriminates against them.

‘If you won’t pay your taxes, you won’t have proof that east Jerusalem is the center of your life and if you can’t prove that, you will lose your residency,” Association for Civil Rights in Israel’s Nisreen  Alyan explains. This means that one becomes stateless, a refugee.

‘Before [Palestinian residents of Jerusalem] find money to feed their children, they pay their taxes,’ Alyan says.

Tsur Baher, along with neighboring Umm Tuba, pays approximately $7 mn in taxes annually to a municipality they do not get to vote for.”

And what is the breakdown of services they receive for those taxes?

The sports department offers the most dramatic example – only 0.5 per cent of funds are allocated to Palestinian neighbourhoods. The other 99.5 per cent goes to Jewish areas.”

Daniel Dukarevich, in my recent interview, cited the different living conditions of Palestinians in East Jerusalem as something that made him become an activist. My worry, though, is that many Israelis don’t know about Palestinian living conditions or blame it on the Palestinians themselves, when it is clearly a matter of government policy.  The article concludes with an anonymous Israeli Jew giving their read on the unspoken reason for such grave discrepancies.

It’s a kind of psychological warfare. The idea is to get [Palestinians] to leave.”

Written by

JESSE BACON (Philadelphia) is a freelance activist and father. He has a Masters in teaching from Roosevelt University in Chicago. He is an observant progressive Jew, and is trying to be a good ally for Palestinians and all dispossessed peoples, while staying true to the best traditions in Judaism. He visited Israel and Palestine in 1996, 2001, and 2002. He served for three years on the local steering committee of Jewish Voice for Peace-Chicago, and one year on the board of Pursue the Peace in Seattle. Read his posts here.

Filed under: On The Ground Reports · Tags: , , ,

Comments are closed.